Vengeance is Mine Says the Lord

vengeance is mine says the lord

Vengeance is Mine Says the Lord

Reflections on Revenge and Justice: A Christian Perspective in the Wake of Charlie Kirk’s Tragic Murder

In the wake of tragedy, our hearts grapple with questions of justice, anger, and the pursuit of peace through faith. On September 10, 2025, conservative activist Charlie Kirk was assassinated during an event at Utah Valley University, a shocking act of violence that has stirred deep emotions. As news of the suspect’s arrest spreads, conversations about vengeance and justice intensify.

From a Christian, particularly Catholic, perspective, this moment calls us to reflect on the words of Scripture: “Vengeance is Mine, says the Lord” (Romans 12:19). Drawing on the Holy Bible, Church teaching, and the guidance of the Holy Spirit, we explore how to respond not with personal revenge, but with trust in God’s wrath and mercy, seeking righteousness through forgiveness and grace.

Summarize at:

Understanding Revenge vs. Avenge: Clarifying the Terms

The terms revenge and avenge are often confused, but God’s Word in Scripture provides clear distinctions, especially vital in times of grief like Kirk’s murder, where anger and hatred can cloud judgment.

Aspect

Revenge

Avenge

Motivation

Acts out of personal anger, hatred, or the desire to “get even.” It is a self-directed retaliation, often fueled by evil intentions.

Performed on behalf of another (or on God’s behalf) to restore right order; the motive is justice, not personal spite, aligned with righteousness.

Object

The wrongdoer is punished because the avenger seeks personal satisfaction, often perpetuating evil.

The wrongdoer is punished because a higher moral law has been violated, and the victim’s dignity must be restored through God’s justice.

Moral evaluation

Considered “malice” and “odious to the Lord” (Tertullian), condemned as “evil repaid with evil.” Personal revenge is sinful, opposing God’s mercy.

Recognized in Scripture as legitimate when God declares, “Vengeance is Mine, says the Lord” (Rom 12:19, World English Bible), or when a person acts as God’s instrument of justice (e.g., “I will avenge my people”).

Typical language

A noun (“revenge”) or verb (“to revenge”) emphasizing the personal act.

A verb (“to avenge”) implying representation of another’s cause, often tied to God’s vengeance.

Everyday example

“I will hurt him because he hurt me,” driven by personal revenge.

“I will bring the thief before the authorities so that justice is done for the victim,” reflecting God’s justice.

Christian teaching, rooted in the New Testament and Old Testament, condemns revenge. In a homily on Romans, St. John Chrysostom tells us that “we must not avenge ourselves, but give place to God’s wrath,” urging us to leave vengeance to the Lord God (Rom 12:19). The Church teaches that personal revenge “does not render justice to the victims, but rather foments revenge,” perpetuating a cycle of evil.

Avenge, however, is proper only when it aligns with God’s vengeance or when legitimate authorities, guided by divine law, administer punishment. The Catechism of the Ukrainian Catholic Church emphasizes that true justice flows from the “logic of forgiveness,” with final judgment belonging to God.

Even in popular culture, like The Avengers, the name suggests acting for others to combat evil, protecting the innocent without personal gain. This mirrors the Christian sense of avenging as a just act, not revenge driven by hatred or personal vendetta.

Summary: Revenge is personal, angry retaliation, morally condemned as evil. Avenge is an act of justice for another or God, permissible when aligned with divine law. Understanding this helps us heed the Apostle Paul’s call in Romans 12:19 to “leave room for God’s wrath” and avoid the sin of personal revenge.

Biblical Insights on Vengeance and Revenge

The Holy Bible frequently addresses vengeance and revenge, underscoring that justice belongs to the Lord God. The exact count varies by translation:

  • In the King James Version, “vengeance” appears roughly 45 times, and “revenge” about 23 times.

  • In the Catholic NRSV-CE, “vengeance” occurs in about 30 verses, and “revenge” in roughly 13.

  • The World English Bible similarly reflects these themes, with Romans 12:19 proclaiming, “Vengeance is Mine, I will repay, saith the Lord.”

These counts, drawn from concordances like Bible Gateway and Bible Hub, vary due to translations rendering Hebrew or Greek terms differently (e.g., “revenge,” “vengeance,” “recompence,” or “retribute”). The Old Testament’s law of retaliation (“eye for an eye,” Deuteronomy 19:21) and prophetic calls to trust in God’s vengeance resonate throughout Scripture, even beyond specific words.

Key passages illustrate this theme:

Passage

Translation (NRSV-CE unless noted)

Theme

Ezekiel 25

“I will lay my vengeance on Edom…” 

God’s sovereign judgment

Psalm 58

“The righteous will rejoice … when they see vengeance done”

Human longing for divine justice

Jeremiah 50

“For this is the vengeance of the Lord” 

National judgment on Babylon, reflecting God’s wrath

Romans 12:19 (cited by Chrysostom)

“Vengeance is mine; I will repay, says the Lord”

Call to leave vengeance to God

Deuteronomy 19:21

“Show no pity: life for life, eye for eye…”

Law of proportional retaliation, tempered by New Testament grace

Cyprian Treatise X

“To me belongs vengeance; I will repay, says the Lord”

Patristic affirmation of God’s vengeance

These verses emphasize that vengeance belongs to the Lord, not humans. The New Testament, through the teachings of Jesus Christ (Matt 5:38-44), redirects believers from revenge to forgiveness, saying, “Thou shalt heap coals of fire on thine enemy’s head” by showing kindness (Rom 12:20). This counters the evil of personal revenge with love, trusting in God’s anger and judgment. Bible study reveals that the frequent mention of vengeance—approximately 45 times in the KJV—reinforces its divine nature, urging us to leave wrath to God.

Why does this matter? Scripture’s emphasis on God’s vengeance helps Christians balance righteous anger with the call to avoid personal revenge. Romans 12:19, echoed by the Apostle Paul, reminds us that only God’s wrath delivers true justice, not human vengeance driven by evil motives.

In short: “Vengeance is Mine, I will repay, saith the Lord” (Rom 12:19, World English Bible) appears dozens of times across translations. Scripture consistently urges entrusting judgment to God, avoiding the evil of revenge.

Summarize at:

The Opposite of Revenge: Forgiveness, Mercy, and Love

Catholic tradition, guided by the Holy Spirit, teaches that the opposite of revenge is forgiveness, enriched by mercy and love. Revenge, driven by anger and hatred, perpetuates evil, while forgiveness breaks the cycle, restoring dignity and inviting sinners to repentance. Mercy reflects God’s compassionate disposition, and love seeks the good of the enemy, even amidst pain.

Key points:

  • Forgiveness: “And forgive us our trespasses, as we forgive those who trespass against us” (Lord’s Prayer, CCC 2844) – forgiveness is the antidote to vengeance, turning from evil to grace.

  • Mercy: “Mercy can penetrate our hearts only if we ourselves learn how to ”forgive”—God’s mercy replaces punishment with pardon, countering God’s anger with love.

  • Love/Compassion: Pope Francis, in Fratelli Tutti 264, calls us to love our enemies, transforming vengeance into healing through the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ.

Thus, in Catholic teaching, forgiveness, mercy, and self-sacrificial love oppose the evil of revenge, leading to righteousness and eternal life.

Applying This to the Present Tragedy

Charlie Kirk’s murder is a profound loss, sparking anger and cries for justice. Yet, as Christians, we are called by the Lord Jesus to reject personal revenge and pray for the victim’s soul, Erika and the children, his family, and even the evil person responsible. Legitimate authorities may administer justice, but personal vengeance fuels evil.

Instead, we trust in God’s wrath and the Lord’s vengeance, as “Vengeance is Mine, I will repay, saith the Lord” (Rom 12:19). By showing mercy, we reflect God’s mercy, and by loving our enemy, we heap coals of kindness, fostering repentance.

In this painful time, let faith guide us to advocate for justice through peaceful means, trusting in Father God’s judgment. May the Holy Spirit grant us grace to forgive, seeking a world free from such evil.

Let us pray

Eternal rest grant unto Charlie Kirk, O Lord, and let perpetual light shine upon him.

May the souls of all the faithful departed, through the mercy of God, rest in peace. Amen.

Requiem aeternam dona eis, Domine. Et lux perpetua luceat eis.

Fidelium animae, per misericordiam Dei, requiescant in pace. Amen.

Summarize at:

Spes et Gaudium

Get weekly reflections in your inbox — subscribe on Spes et Gaudium on Substack.

Subscribe on Substack