Magnifica Humanitas: Choosing Babel or Jerusalem in the Age of AI

magnifica humanitas

I recently finished reading Pope Leo XIV’s encyclical Magnifica Humanitas. I took a full semester on Catholic Social Teaching (CST) during my apologetics studies, and I appreciated how the document begins with a clear, robust reiteration of Social Doctrine, the Church’s formal term for the same living tradition, before applying it to the realities of AI, technology, and contemporary life.

It’s deep, rich, and not a fast read if you’ve never studied CST, so read the first chapter slowly and highlight heavily. This foundation is worth savoring. The chapters function like strong thematic pillars. Each one builds upon the last, creating a coherent moral architecture.

At the center of the encyclical is the Incarnation. God became human in Jesus Christ. In Christ, the true mystery and dignity of humanity become clear, and this truth becomes the lens through which the Church reads every technological development. Rather than judging AI by speed, profit, or power, the document consistently asks whether it respects, protects, and helps real human persons as God intended us to be.

Summarize at:

The Dignity of the Person

Through this lens, the encyclical frames today’s crisis as a fundamental choice: humanity can construct a new Tower of Babel (a plan that dominates and dehumanizes) or rebuild Jerusalem (a shared project of responsibility and communion).

Tower of Babel: Genesis 11:1-9

In the land of Shinar, the people of the earth, who all spoke one language, decided to build a great city and a tower reaching to the heavens in order to make a name for themselves and avoid being scattered.

Using bricks and bitumen, they began this ambitious project. The Lord came down to see what they were doing and recognized that their unity and common language would allow them to accomplish almost anything they set their minds to.

To prevent this prideful and self-glorifying endeavor, God confused their language so they could no longer understand one another, and He scattered them across the face of the earth.

The city was left unfinished and was called Babel, because that is where the Lord confused the language of all the earth.

Rebuilding of Jerusalem: Neh 1–6

In the book of Nehemiah, the story begins with Nehemiah, a Jewish cupbearer to the Persian king Artaxerxes, learning from visitors that Jerusalem’s walls are broken down and its people are in great distress and shame.

Deeply moved, he mourns, fasts, and prays, confessing the sins of Israel and asking God to remember His covenant and grant him favor. Later, while serving the king, Nehemiah boldly requests permission to return to Jerusalem to rebuild the city. The king grants his request, providing letters of safe passage and resources.

Upon arriving, Nehemiah secretly inspects the ruined walls at night, then rallies the people with a vision of restoration. Despite opposition and ridicule from enemies like Sanballat and Tobiah, the people commit to the work. They organize by families to rebuild sections of the wall while remaining vigilant against threats, working with tools in one hand and weapons in the other.

Nehemiah encourages them to remember God’s greatness and fight for their families and homes. Through prayer, unity, and perseverance, they complete the wall in just 52 days, and their enemies recognize that the work was accomplished with God’s help.

These two stories are the main biblical images the encyclical uses to contrast prideful, self-centered projects (Babel) with faithful, communal, God-centered restoration (Jerusalem).

Technology is never neutral in practice. It reflects the intentions and values of those who develop, finance, regulate, and use it.

Summarize at:

The Five Pillars

Pillar 1 → The Church’s Role and Method

Before applying Social Doctrine to AI, the encyclical explains how the Church relates to the world. I love how Pope Leo eloquently explains the Church’s role. She walks alongside humanity, recognizes the autonomy of earthly realities, and distinguishes ecclesial from political spheres.

When the Church intervenes in urgent wounds, she does so with evangelical charity, following the example of the Good Samaritan with discretion and closeness, so that help does not replace the institutional responsibilities of civil society.

Lay takeaway:

Your role as a lay person isn’t to take over civil or technical institutions but to apply Christian moral judgment in your workplace, family life, and civic involvement. We must support just structures and honest accountability and offer formation and charity in how we speak about technology and its harms.

The Church wants to help the lay faithful implement Social Doctrine in daily life and relationships, work, and society.

Pillar 2 → Foundations of Social Doctrine

The encyclical defines Social Doctrine as a living reality. It is in dialogue with history, cultures, and sciences while protecting a core set of unchanging truths. It highlights a foundation or blueprint for interpreting new things of the age, especially in light of AI, by renewing focus on the common good, universal destination of goods, subsidiarity and solidarity, and social justice.

It teaches that integral human development is a key measure for judging real progress, including in the digital revolution. Technological innovations are evaluated by whether they help people become more humane and fraternal while respecting creation and future generations.

The encyclical also carefully protects human dignity from being reduced to performance or usefulness. It distinguishes types of dignity and then emphasizes ontological dignity: human beings have value simply by virtue of existing, willed by God; no sin, failure, humiliation, or exclusion can diminish the profound value of a human life.

Lay takeaway:

When you ask, “Is this AI policy or feature good?” you’re not only asking about convenience or efficiency; you’re asking, “Does it serve the common good and protect rights? Does it treat persons as ends, not as cogs or means? Does it strengthen integral human flourishing, especially for the vulnerable?”

Pillar 3 → AI, Human Limits, and the Technocratic Challenge

The encyclical critiques the technocratic paradigm: when technology becomes the standard for judging everything, it can reduce creation to exploitation and humans to mere cogs.

Human intelligence, with its conscience and freedom, must guide innovation and determine its limits. AI imitates certain functions of human intelligence but does not undergo experiences, does not possess a body, does not feel joy or pain, and lacks moral conscience.

The encyclical addresses transhumanist and posthumanist currents that reinterpret progress as surpassing the human condition. It recognizes the yearning behind them but points instead to the pathway opened by the Incarnation.

Lay takeaway:

The practical implication is not to fear technology but to refuse any worldview that treats efficiency and control as ultimate goods, treats persons as instruments, or imagines a salvation that bypasses embodied human weakness and relationships. Instead, the Gospel’s Incarnation-centered path calls for freedom, moral responsibility, and solidarity, so technology remains truly human.

Pillar 4 → Truth, Work, and Freedom in the Digital Age

The encyclical connects digital transformation to moral-social questions: societies must rediscover truth as a common good, protect the dignity of work, and safeguard freedom against dependence and commercialization.

Digital platforms and AI can blur truth and falsehood and amplify disinformation. Truthful information requires careful verification and responsible argumentation and is also built through trust and shared practices.

Those who control technological and economic power can strongly influence what people believe about humanity, the world, meaning, family, and even God.

Those who control platforms strongly shape inner freedom.

Lay takeaway:

Your role tends to look like practicing disciplined verification (not sharing automatically); cultivating critical thought and honest dialogue; refusing to let algorithms shape your thinking; and supporting family and community formation that helps people, especially the young, resist manipulation and keep truth-loving habits. The encyclical treats these activities as part of safeguarding freedom and dignity, not as optional digital hygiene.

Pillar 5 → Power, Peace, and the Civilization of Love

Chapter Five links the digital revolution to the tragic issue of war. I was surprised to see him mention that the Just War doctrine of the Church, in the strictest sense, is irrelevant and abused.

The encyclical notes that technology detached from ethics can make decisions about life and death more rapid and impersonal. It describes new forms of conflict and warns that AI can lower the threshold for force and shield responsibility.

The encyclical contrasts the Babel-like logic of power and pride with the Jerusalem rebuilding logic of patience and shared responsibility. It calls for recovering the heart of Social Doctrine, the “civilization of love”: translating charity into structures of justice, giving institutional form to fraternity, and regarding others as allies necessary for building the common good.

The encyclical discusses responsible action and daily fidelity in the face of technological change. It emphasizes that we don’t need to control or master everything, but rather faithfully do the part that is given to us in our time and place.

It uses J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Lord of the Rings to illustrate this point. Spoken by Gandalf in The Fellowship of the Ring,

“It is not our part to master all the tides of the world, but to do what is in us for the succour of those years wherein we are set, uprooting the evil in the fields that we know, so that those who live after may have clean earth to till.”

The Pope uses this quote to encourage readers not to be overwhelmed by the scale of technological and cultural challenges but to act faithfully in their own sphere (family, work, community, ministry), trusting that small, steady acts of fidelity contribute to the larger rebuilding of a more human world.

The conclusion proposes a sober yet demanding Christian program for navigating AI change in the light of the Gospel. It culminates in a spirituality of ecclesial unity in love, inviting us to contemplate God’s plan, live unity through the Eucharist, build a world centered on the common good, and pray in union with Mary.

In a world of new networks that can generate exclusion, the Church is called to preserve human connections, give voice to the invisible, and direct processes toward respecting dignity.

Lay takeaway:

Your concrete goal is not just holding correct opinions but living a Eucharist-shaped life. This means defending human dignity in everyday relationships and public life, supporting institutions and policies that prevent domination and injustice, working for genuine peace (including accountability around technology’s role in conflict), and keeping unity and truthfulness at the center of everything.

One Coherent Thread

In the age of AI, the Church asks you to choose a Jerusalem-building faithfulness guided by Social Doctrine (dignity, common good, subsidiarity, and solidarity); lived through truth-loving freedom; aimed at peace; and fed by the Eucharist.

Final Thought

After reading the document, my notes, and some research, I noticed something interesting. I noticed a clear pattern of words I hadn’t seen used so frequently since my Catholic Social Teaching class. Purely anecdotally and not scientifically, terms like “solidarity” and “subsidiarity” appear almost exclusively in the context of CST. After seeing them repeated so often, I asked Grok to analyze the full text and list the top ten most frequent significant words. Here is what it found.

The language of the encyclical clearly reveals its central concerns. After removing common connecting words, the most frequent significant terms are:

human / humanity (112 times)

dignity (68)

AI (42)

person / persons (41)

common good (35)

social doctrine (27)

love (26)

technology / technological (25)

freedom (22)

solidarity (18)

This distribution confirms that the document is not primarily a technical treatise on AI but a profound reflection on safeguarding human dignity in the age of powerful new technologies. While “AI” appears frequently, the emphasis remains firmly on the human person, the common good, and the enduring principles of Social Doctrine. It is a timely and much-needed reintroduction of Catholic Social Teaching for our digital age.

Magnificat anima mea Dominum.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Magnifica Humanitas

What is the main message of Magnifica Humanitas? The encyclical calls the Church and the world to choose between building a new Tower of Babel (prideful, dehumanizing systems) or rebuilding Jerusalem (communal, God-centered restoration). It applies Catholic Social Doctrine to the age of AI, insisting that technology must serve human dignity rather than replace or reduce it (paras. 7–9, 130).

Why does the encyclical focus so much on human dignity? It emphasizes ontological dignity — the value every person has simply by existing, willed and loved by God. No technology, failure, or circumstance can erase this dignity (para. 52). This is the foundation for judging all AI development and digital practices.

What does “Babel or Jerusalem” mean in this context? Babel represents projects driven by pride, uniformity, and self-glorification that lead to confusion and scattering. Jerusalem represents faithful, shared labor with God at the center, restoring relationships and community (Genesis 11:1-9 and the Book of Nehemiah).

How should lay Catholics apply this encyclical? The document stresses that Social Doctrine is meant for daily life. Laypeople are called to bring moral judgment into their work, family, and civic life; support just structures; practice discernment with technology; and live a Eucharist-shaped life of unity, truth, and care for the vulnerable.

Does the encyclical say AI is bad? No. It recognizes AI as a powerful tool but insists it must remain under human intelligence, conscience, and moral guidance. AI imitates functions of intelligence but lacks body, experience, and moral conscience (para. 99).

What is the “civilization of love” in the document? It is the positive vision the Church proposes: translating charity into structures of justice and fraternity, so that digital interdependence becomes genuine solidarity instead of new forms of exclusion and domination (para. 186 and conclusion).

Is this encyclical only for Catholics? While rooted in Catholic Social Doctrine, the message is addressed to all people of goodwill. It invites everyone to consider how we can safeguard human dignity in the age of AI.

Summarize at:

Spes et Gaudium

Get weekly reflections in your inbox — subscribe on Spes et Gaudium on Substack.

Subscribe on Substack